Experts say addressing the root causes of police misconduct, targeting minority communities, is the real challenge for authorities.
Brad Brooks, Reuters
Last summer, millions of ordinary Americans took to the streets to protest racism, police violence and the killing of George Floyd.
In the year since, many transformed their energy and anger to action. Across the country, civilians on task forces and elected officials in state legislatures are pushing for changes that experts say address the root causes of police misconduct targeting minority communities. Reforms at state and local levels in the past year include the creation of oversight boards that are not beholden to police departments or unions.
“You cannot just ask the police to do their reforms themselves - it won’t get done,” said Robert Davis, a pastor who coordinates a civilian-led task force in Denver that is preparing a report on proposed changes for police. “We have to empower the community to be responsible for public safety.”
Community efforts have existed for generations, and modernizing the roughly 18,000 individual police departments in the United States is a messy, fragmented and difficult task. But policing experts say that efforts now go beyond addressing tactics — such as banning choke holds.
“There is a deeper questioning around not just resources and tactics, but in asking ‘what are we trying to accomplish?’” said Tracie Keesee, who spent 25 years as a police officer in Denver before co-founding the Center of Policing Equity. “People are genuinely trying to do something new.”
Keesee sees civilians making progress in places such as Ithaca, New York, where she worked with the mayor’s office that recommended the replacement of the police department with a “community solutions” public safety agency — an idea rejected by the local police union. She also cited a move in Austin, Texas, to cut the police budget by a third and use some of that money to address social issues like homelessness.
Austin is a left-leaning island in a conservative state where the Republican governor, Greg Abbott, is pushing legislation that would withhold some state tax revenue for cities that cut police budgets. That points to hurdles ahead for reformers.
Jeffrey Fagan, a Columbia University criminal justice scholar, said the federal government has an important role in policing reform. But he is increasingly convinced that state-level efforts hold more promise at getting at the roots of police misconduct.
“That is the future of police reform,” he said.
He called reforms including a police oversight committee that were pushed through the Massachusetts state legislature and signed into law by another Republican governor, Charlie Baker, in December “remarkable.” That they came from elected state officials “has a very powerful legitimizing effect,” Fagan said.
Maryland’s Democratic-led legislature on Saturday also passed aggressive police reforms, overriding three vetoes from Republican Governor Larry Hogan.
Jonathan Blanks, a visiting fellow at the Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity who focuses on policing, said people often look to Washington for help with big, systemic problems. But officials in DC do not have much authority over local police departments, he said.
Days before former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin went on trial last month for murder in Floyd’s death, the “George Floyd Justice in Policing Act” was passed with little Republican support in the Democratic-controlled US House of Representatives.
Among its provisions, the bill proposes restricting certain funds to local governments that let law enforcement officers use choke holds, requiring law enforcement agencies to provide data on use of deadly force, and changing “qualified immunity” to further open the door for lawsuits against police over the use of excessive force. The bill’s prospects were uncertain in the Senate, where the Democrats’ majority is slim and some moderate Democrats have joined Republicans in expressing concern the proposal would divert funds that police need and make communities less safe.
At last some light at the end of a tunnel of despair and persistent persecution based on deep-seated prejudice. For years citizens of colour in the United States have been confronting racial bias in the streets of hatred and violence –– all aimed at them, by a
George Floyd pleading for his life under the knee of a Minneapolis police officer has become a defining moment of our time. What began 10 months ago at the corner of 38th Street and Chicago Avenue has transformed into nothing less than an
President Joe Biden has begun to show that he is a man who can deliver. In a first of its kind and as a landmark gesture towards diversity in courts, Biden nominated several Black women, an Asian-American and the first Muslim ever to federal
After almost a year, the country finally received the verdict in the case against former Minneapolis officer Derek Chauvin, who murdered George Floyd last May by pressing his knee into Floyd’s neck for 8 minutes and 46 seconds. To our collective
The rapid drop in daily COVID-19 cases in the United Arab Emirates is a huge success of the visionary leadership of the United Arab Emirates
After he dismissed the government of prime minister Hichem Mechichi on July 25, suspended parliament, put on hold the salaries of the lawmakers,
The gradual US disengagement from this region in favour of a pivot toward Asia has launched a process of reconciliation among countries which have been estranged by competition and rivalries.