When it comes to recent tech outages, there have been a lot of coincidences. Some would say too many. The US grounded all departing flights — for only the second time since the September 11 attacks 25 years ago. Microsoft, the linchpin of the entire English legal system, was down for nearly 24 hours, weeks after the company announced 60,000 job cuts. And earlier this week, several American banks were down. Back in the UK, the National Grid has had to publicly deny an online hoax claiming that the release of Grand Theft Auto 6 will trigger power outages tomorrow.
Then there was the brief Apple outage on Tuesday, and the National Security Agency’s temporary outage on its internal network. One cyber insider told me it’s all a bit like “the old stories about UFOs. If a big report comes out, then it’s worth running all the stories, and suddenly there appear to be loads of problems. The baseline number of reports hasn’t changed. What has changed is the newsworthiness threshold”.
But that isn’t all that has changed. The American public’s wafer-thin tolerance for being asked to prepare for danger and then be told there isn’t any seems to have snapped. Even Karoline Leavitt, once a loyal press secretary to Donald Trump’s White House, told Fox News that the government should come clean on tech outages, adding that “transparency is key”.
When the public doesn’t believe what the state is telling them, that is obviously bad. This spate of significant outages has taken out much of our increasingly digitally dependent way of life — and whether it’s Russia, Iran or a cleaner unplugging a key socket to do the hoovering, everything feels distinctly leery. In the UK, the haze of Covid lingers in the air. Economic pressures and uncertainty from the USA emphasise this yet further — and then there’s the fact that both MI5 and GCHQ have been very plainly telling us to take cybersecurity seriously and get our houses in order.
However much company comms departments may trill that everything’s fine and there have been zero cyberattacks, it’s extremely clear that everything is very much not fine, although it may have become our new normal — not helped by Silicon Valley reporting that their every brilliant, beautiful new toy will either kill us or replace us, but that we should definitely use it every day and pay for the privilege.
And back here, more than one person I have spoken to feels distinctly gaslit by this cycle of being “nudged” by government advice into anxious prepping, making our way to supermarket checkouts laden with five-litre bottles of water and batteries for the radio, only to be told not to get agitated by another major plank of modern life suddenly and mysteriously turning off. Keep calm and carry on stockpiling. It is, at the very least, a total disasterclass in the art of comms.
A combination of geopolitics, the speed of tech advancement and AI discovering vulnerabilities at unprecedented speeds means we need to urgently straighten out the old days of sloppy attitudes to cyber hygiene. The British Library may have been hacked, yes. But the hackers that took down M&S and Jaguar Land Rover started with “social engineering”, gaining access to the systems through its staff. We still think of hacking as something happening remotely; today, it’s more like a nice chap ringing you up and claiming to be Dave from IT.
And if we are to pay attention to what the big-boy departments are telling us this year, albeit in the restrained formality of official statements that sink without trace in an age of social media, we are right to worry. Or, if not worry, then to take things seriously. The UK currently has no award system for businesses’ cybersecurity to help customers choose who they entrust with their information and money. Perhaps there should be. At the very least, to know that they are all signed up to the National Cyber Security Centre’s (NCSC) Active Cyber Defence services, which act as an early warning system against attack.
For the civil service — and specifically, GCHQ, the NCSC and MI5 – has been shrieking about resilience.