US Vice President Kamala Harris arrives to hold a ceremonial swearing-in for Veterans Affairs (VA) Secretary Denis McDonough at the White House in Washington. File/Reuters
Noah Bierman, Tribune News Service
Soon after Joe Biden announced last year that he would pick a woman as his running mate, US Rep. Jackie Speier began warning Facebook executives: female politicians receive the most vile online attacks, and the company’s filters were failing to stop them.
“We showed them 20 examples that were disgusting — and they were still up!” said Speier, a California Democrat, whose meetings included one with Chief Operating Officer Sheryl Sandberg. Facebook’s response gave her little comfort. “Keep sending us these horrific examples,” she said executives told her, “and we’ll take them down.”
Speier’s concerns that the first female vice president would attract outsize assaults and venomous lies from social media’s ugliest players have now been validated. Research shows that Kamala Harris may be the most targeted American politician on the internet, one who checks every box for the haters of the fever swamps: she’s a woman, she’s a person of colour and she holds power.
It’s not just the amount but the type of harassment that makes the Harris slurs stand out. President Joe Biden gets his share of smears, but they tend to focus on his age, often repeating former President Donald Trump’s “Sleepy Joe” moniker; a few call him creepy or worse. Those directed at Harris, however, tend to reference sex, violence or misogynistic accusations that she does not deserve her position.
“Abuse directed at women is highly personalised, often attacking them based on their appearance and denigrating their intelligence,” said Cecile Guerin, a researcher in London at the Institute for Strategic Dialogue, a think tank that seeks to counter extremism, disinformation and polarisation. “It is also more likely to imply that they should quit politics and that they don’t belong in the public space.”
Guerin led a recent study that did not include Harris but showed that American female politicians were two to three times more likely to receive abusive Twitter comments than male counterparts.
Such findings elevate widespread concerns that women, still significantly underrepresented in political and corporate offices, will avoid or give up leadership jobs that leave them vulnerable to online abuse. “It certainly discourages women from getting engaged in politics,” Speier said, given worries about family and personal safety.
For example, some female members of the British Parliament cited online abuse and threats in declining to run for re-election in 2019, prompting advocates there to push for better online safety training.
“I think a lot of people don’t understand until they’ve gone through this sort of thing how much time it takes, how exhausting it is,” said Nina Jankowicz, a fellow at the Wilson Center whose focus on the topic has made her a target of disinformation and harassment as well.
The Jan. 6 attacks on the Capitol exposed a thinning membrane between the online world and the real one, with public figures subject to actual threats from individuals or groups inflamed by content on social media. It is no longer hard, for example, to imagine violent conspiracists acting on the posted lies that Harris is a plant bent on taking over the government.
Online attacks against Harris, now that she is vice president, are monitored by the Secret Service. Her aides declined to comment other than to say threats to her and her family are taken seriously.
Facebook and other social media companies defend their efforts to detect and remove harassing content but concede that some material, especially coded or sarcastic posts, eludes automated filters powered by artificial intelligence. Jankowicz described several such tactics, such as sending images of empty egg cartons to women in their 30s who do not have children, an implication that they are infertile and bitter.
Jankowicz led a study released last month analysing more than 300,000 posts against 13 politicians in four English-speaking countries in the couple of months before the US election. Harris was targeted in 78% of the posts, more than other high-profile women of colour in the study, such as Democratic Reps. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York and Ilhan Omar of Minnesota, the leading targets of abuse on Twitter and Facebook in Guerin’s study.
Older white women such as Sen. Susan Collins, a Maine Republican, were less likely to be the target of gender-based attacks than younger women or women of colour. Even a younger Republican woman with a high profile, Rep. Elise Stefanik of New York, did not receive as many attacks as her Democratic counterparts in Congress. Jankowicz’s study did not include Facebook because the data set was more complete from six other platforms, including Twitter.
It showed that many of the attacks and disinformation lobbed at Harris echoed tropes against Barack and Michelle Obama: that she is insufficiently Black or Indian because of her mixed-race heritage, that she cannot legally serve as vice president because her parents were immigrants, that she slept her way to the top, that she has a secret plan to steal authority from Biden and, perhaps most outlandish, that she is secretly a man.
That last lie, apparently started by the QAnon cult, involves what’s known as a “cheap fake,” a crudely doctored image of Harris alongside a man supposedly named Kamal Aroush.
Jankowicz said the anti-transgender smears levelled at Michelle Obama and Harris, though not as rampant as other misinformation, follow a pattern of targeting women in power with a twisted misogynistic logic: “There’s no way that you can be in a position of power. There has to be something duplicitous about you. It must be that you’re a man.”
Other posts involved more direct attacks using racist and sexist language and images.
Nathan Barankin, Harris’ former Senate chief of staff and a top deputy when she was California’s attorney general, said the abuse isn’t new, only the volume and intensity are. “I am unaware of any job she has ever had in which there were not a steady stream of very real and viable threats to her safety,” he said. “And those are physical, digital, email and otherwise.”
Barankin would not disclose security precautions taken for Harris in her prior positions, but said they were greater than for other officials because of the nature of the threats.
Speier, who co-chairs the House Democratic Women’s Caucus and has been active on the issue of online harassment, said she has quit collecting examples of toxic material for Facebook. The problem is too big and the company won’t hire enough staff to police it, she said. Besides, she added, the algorithms are still biased toward elevating explosive material.
For the congresswoman, concern that threats and misguided beliefs can turn deadly is hardly hypothetical. In 1978, Speier survived five gunshot wounds when her boss, Rep. Leo Ryan, was assassinated by cult members during the Jonestown massacre in Guyana. Since the Jan. 6 Capitol siege, she noted, lawmakers were authorised to use their office budgets on bulletproof vests. She has yet to buy one.
More than a handful of Republicans are already sniffing around the 2024 presidential contest. Texas Sen. Ted Cruz, Missouri Sen. Josh Hawley, South Carolina Sen. Tim Scott, Arkansas Sen. Tom Cotton, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, former
Biden traces his ancestry to Ireland. His great-great grandfathers called Bluett and Fitzpatrick were born in Ireland and emigrated to the US in the late 1840s and early 1850s.
Barack Obama campaigned for president in 2008 with explicit advice from his inner circle to downplay “any topic that might be labeled racial grievance” or to “do anything that would box me in as ‘the Black candidate,’” he wrote in his recent memoir.
President Joe Biden is still old. That observation might not seem quite so relevant after Biden delivered a spirited State of the Union address on Tuesday night that accomplished all the White House could reasonably have hoped for. Biden, 80, rattled off meaningful achievements, slathered on some bipartisanship with a salute
The Writers Guild of America (WGA) and the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers have reached a draft agreement which is to be ratified by members of WGA. This was preceded by a 148-day strike, which began on May 2. This was a protest against the use of AI in the work of writers, and giving
The federal government is just days away from a shutdown that will disrupt many services, squeeze workers and roil politics as Republicans in the House, fueled by hard-right demands, force a confrontation over federal spending.
The feds are coming after Google. In January, the Department of Justice filed an antitrust lawsuit alleging that the technology giant monopolised the lucrative space of digital advertising. A sure-to-be exhaustive trial underway in the US District Court in Washington is expected to last until November.
A few days before attending a small gathering of friends, I came down with cold, allergy, flu or possibly COVID-19 symptoms. It was at the beginning of what has become a summer surge of COVID-19 cases, and though I had tested negative for COVID-19 twice over 48 hours, I decided it was still better to not attend.