Jussie Smollett and Kim Foxx.
Set aside, for a moment, the issue of race in the Jussie Smollett case. Think of it first as an issue of darkness and light. Darkness as in the veil of silence and secrecy Cook County State’s Attorney Kim Foxx has draped over the machinations in her office that resulted in Smollett being able to proclaim his innocence in the lobby of the very courthouse in which he was supposed to get his comeuppance.
Darkness as in the shadow this case is casting over Foxx’s effort to operate a smarter, fairer justice system. Light as in the illumination that Foxx and her communications team should, but seem pathologically unwilling to, shed on a story that for better or worse — but largely for worse — continues to generate significant local controversy.
And light as in the new dawn that must break in the damaged relationship between “two separate yet equally important groups — the police who investigate crime and the district attorneys who prosecute the offenders,” to quote the famous intro to NBC’s “Law & Order.”
The background: On Feb. 20, Jussie Smollett, a gay, African-American TV actor, was charged with filing a false police report after allegedly staging a hate-inspired attack against himself in Chicago’s Streeterville neighbourhood in the early morning hours of Jan. 29. The alleged attack and the subsequent allegation that it had been staged became international news. But then on March 26, with no warning to reporters or police and no real explanation, Foxx’s office dropped all of the charges against Smollett.
The latest: On Tuesday the Sun-Times reported that on March 13, nearly two weeks before the Smollett exoneration controversy erupted, Foxx’s office quietly made a similar decision to dismiss a lower-profile but still newsworthy case.
In March 2016, Jose Maldonado, then the chief of the Chicago Heights Park District Police Department, was charged with speeding, drunken driving, carrying a gun while intoxicated and other offenses after allegedly committing a traffic violation that began on an expressway ramp, an incident that was reported at the time by WLS-Ch. 7. The Sun-Times reported that Foxx sent a letter to Maldonado’s attorney saying, “we have determined that the appropriate disposition is to dismiss the criminal charges against your client (and) our decision is based solely on a review of the merits of the pending case.”
What? Wait! Why? The Sun-Times reported that Foxx’s press office didn’t respond to a request for an explanation. OK. There’s much to like about prosecutors who seek justice rather than victory by not going forward when they aren’t sure they have proof of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. We should expect no less.
And there’s also much to like about Foxx’s overall efforts to devote public resources to addressing serious violent crime.
But there’s nothing to like about doing it in darkness. That seems like a basic truth. But my view that the Smollett fallout is only about celebrity and secrecy, and not about race, has had to evolve as reaction to the story has consistently referenced race. Foxx, who is African-American, recently stood shoulder to shoulder at a news conference with those who contend that racism animates her critics, just as an all-white group of police chiefs recently stood shoulder to shoulder with the local Fraternal Order of Police to put forth an expression of no confidence in Foxx.
So it is about race now, like it or not. It’s about the widening of a poisonous divide not only between those who enforce the law and the communities that badly need their protection, but also between those who investigate crime and those who prosecute the offenders.
That’s my answer to those who wonder why we keep covering and commenting on this story despite the alleged crime’s insignificance compared with the carnage on our streets nearly every day. The carnage and this controversy will entwine. And the closer we get to the violent months of summer, the more urgent it becomes for Foxx to bring the light.
Venezuelan security forces fired tear gas on Saturday to disperse demonstrators who turned out in Caracas to protest massive power outages that have kept much of the country in darkness since early March. AFP journalists on the scene said the security forces blocked opposition protesters from concentrating at certain points in the western side of the city.
Donald Trump's administration announced Tuesday it was speeding up plans to send US astronauts back to the Moon, from 2028 to 2024, calling for a "spark of urgency" to prevail over delays that have plagued NASA's lunar return plans.
US Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin said on Friday he had a “productive working dinner” the previous night in Beijing, kicking off a day of talks aimed at resolving the bitter trade dispute
The UN children’s agency, Unicef, has called on the homelands of thousands of children of foreign fighters held in camps and orphanages in Syria, Iraq and elsewhere to be reclaimed and repatriated. Unicef says they are “among the world’s most vulnerable children” as they live in “appalling conditions
It has become clear that Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam greatly misjudged the public mood. Though she has taken the rare step of apologising, it does not seem to have convinced the hundreds of thousands of black-clad protesters who have maintained calls for her to resign over her handling of a bill
Repealing the 2017 tax cuts would not just hurt the wealthy and corporations. It would also leave middle-class Americans tens of thousands of dollars poorer. Reversing the tax cuts would cost the typical American worker $26,900 over the following 10 years. And families would be hit even harder: A family of four
In 2017 brave undercover reporting by Callum Tulley and BBC Panorama exposed the appalling abuse of people taking place at Brook House Detention Centre. As a former senior manager at the centre I took part in the film and spoke about the mistreatment I saw. As the High Court has now reminded