Three men embezzled Dhs958,000 from a food trading company, one of them misappropriated the funds, which had been entrusted to him in a fiduciary capacity while the other two participated in the act by way of agreement and assistance.
After being convicted in a criminal case, Dubai Civil Court ordered them to pay Dhs958,000 to the company, this being the embezzled amount, plus Dhs30,000 in financial compensation and 5 per cent annual interest from the date the civil judgment becomes final until full payment is made.
Earlier, a food trading company filed a lawsuit in which it requested the court to obligate the three people to return Dhs958,000, which it said was embezzled from it plus Dhs200,000 in compensation for the material and moral harms it had befallen.
The company stated that Dubai Public Prosecution referred the defendants to trial in a criminal case after charging them with embezzling funds belonging to it, adding that one of the defendants acting in bad faith falsely reported to the authorities that he had been a victim of a robbery by force in an attempt to cover up the incident.
The criminal court sentenced the defendants to one year in jail to be followed by deportation for the charges brought against them and ordered them to jointly pay the embezzled funds.
The criminal judgment established that the first defendant misappropriated the funds he had received in his fiduciary capacity to the detriment of the company, while the second and third defendants participated in this misappropriation by way of agreement and assistance. The company submitted a copy of the criminal judgment, along with a certificate confirming its finality, as part of the evidence in the civil lawsuit.
The first and third defendants failed to appear in court despite having been duly served with legal notice, while the second defendant appeared from his place of detention but did not submit a defence memorandum.
The court held that a final criminal judgment carries binding authority in civil proceedings regarding the matters it has already adjudicated, specifically, the occurrence of the embezzlement and its attribution to the defendants.
The court affirmed that the proven embezzlement of the funds constituted a breach of the company’s financial interests, depriving it of its capital and the opportunity to invest or grow, not to mention the expenses incurred in pursuing the complaint and litigation.
The court hereby assessed the compensation for these material harms at Dhs30,000, which, when added to the amount embezzled, brings the total awarded sum to Dhs988,000.
The court, however, rejected the company’s claim for compensation for moral harms, explaining that a harm to commercial reputation resulting from the reluctance of others to engage in business with it is considered material harm that must be proven.