The Abu Dhabi Family, Civil, and Administrative Cases Court has ordered a defendant to return Dhs147,000 to a plaintiff and pay Dhs25,000 in compensation for material and moral damages.
The dispute arose from an investment agreement to purchase electric vehicles in the UAE and resell them in a neighboring country for profit.
The defendant failed to carry out the agreement, provided no evidence that the vehicles had been purchased, and refused to return the funds despite repeated demands and attempts to reach an amicable settlement.
The plaintiff filed a lawsuit seeking repayment of Dhs147,300, the outstanding balance identified in an expert report cited by the Criminal Court of Appeal, along with Dhs50,000 in compensation for material and moral damages, legal fees, and court costs.
According to the plaintiff, he had given the defendant Dhs150,000 to invest in the purchase and resale of electric vehicles. The defendant neither fulfilled the agreement nor provided proof of any purchases. The plaintiff said he had received no more than Dhs2,700 back from the transaction, while the defendant retained the remaining funds, causing him material and moral harm.
The court noted that a previous criminal judgment had convicted the defendant, establishing his fault and the misappropriation underlying the dispute. It explained that criminal judgments are binding on civil courts insofar as they establish that an act occurred and identify the person responsible. After reviewing the documents and the findings of the criminal proceedings, the court determined that the defendant was obligated to repay Dhs147,000.
The court further found that the defendant’s misappropriation had caused the plaintiff material damages, including the loss of his funds and potential earnings, as well as moral damages in the form of pain, distress, and sorrow. It explained that a lump-sum award may cover all damages suffered, provided the elements supporting the award are specified. Accordingly, the court awarded Dhs25,000 in compensation for those damages.