Ed Miliband to join review of Labour election failure
Ed Miliband. File
Jeremy Corbyn has faced criticism for claiming Labour “won the argument” and writing only a generic letter of thanks to former MPs who lost their seats rather than apologising personally.
Yet the commissioners behind the independent review said it was wrong to blame only Corbyn – or the position on Brexit – for Labour’s heaviest general election loss since 1935.
As well as Miliband, who led the party to its 2015 defeat, former shadow education secretary Lucy Powell and Birmingham Ladywood MP Shabana Mahmood will spearhead the review on behalf of the Labour Together group.
Other confirmed commissioners include Jo Platt, former MP for Leigh – one of the lost seats from Labour’s heartlands in Greater Manchester – Sienna Rodgers, editor of the Labourlist website, and James Meadway, former economic adviser to shadow chancellor John McDonnell.
The review will interview all 59 MPs who lost their seats during the crumbling of Labour’s so-called “red wall” of constituencies in the North, the Midlands and Wales.
Labour Together describes itself as a “network for activists from all traditions of the Labour movement.” A trade union representative, as well as a local organiser, is also expected to join the panel.
“We have lost the last four elections and we all have to accept that our offers to the country have been insufficient,” said Powell, MP for Manchester Central. “We should have taken the time to understand our losses previously.
“It’s now profoundly important for the future of our party and country that we take a real and meaningful look at why we have fallen short. This inquiry gives us the opportunity to listen to members, candidates and the public and I hope our whole movement takes it in the spirit it is offered and takes part.”
The commission, according to a spokesman, aims to “raise above the factional infighting which has coloured much of Labour politics for the last four years.”
It hopes to capitalise on the “millions of conversations” voters had with Labour campaigners in a bid to come up with a plan for Labour’s return to Downing Street.
The party last won an election in 2005 under the leadership of former prime minister Tony Blair.
The former leader of 13 years gave a scathing speech last week, telling an audience in London that the “takeover of the Labour Party by the far-left” had “turned it into a glorified protest movement, with cult trimmings, utterly incapable of being a credible government.”
Laura Pidcock, a close ally of Corbyn, caused a stir on Sunday by has suggesting Blair was still to blame for Labour’s crushing 2019 electoral defeat.
She said the former prime minister’s legacy “hangs around this party like a millstone.”
Meanwhile, Labour MP David Lammy has accused Corbyn of a “mind-boggling” abdication of leadership over Brexit as he said he was considering running to lead the party.
The Tottenham MP criticised Corbyn’s policy of staying neutral on “the biggest issue of the delay” as “triangulation” and claimed that Labour had lost its “moral authority” because of the leadership’s failure to tackle antisemitism.
Lammy said he would decide over the Christmas period whether to enter the leadership contest, which is expected to formally begin in early January.
He would join a contested field that already includes Emily Thornberry, the shadow foreign secretary, and Clive Lewis, the Treasury minister.
Sir Keir Starmer, the shadow Brexit secretary, Rebecca Long Bailey, the shadow business secretary, and Lisa Nandy, the Wigan MP, are all expected to stand, while backbenchers Jess Phillips and Yvette Cooper are also thought to be considering a bid.
Lammy described Corbyn, who he has known for decades as a neighbouring north London MP, as “kind, compassionate and thoroughly decent” but said this view of the Labour leader was not shared by voters.
The Independent
