Justin Forsyth talks to internally displaced Somalis at a camp in the Hodan district of Somalia. Reuters
Janice Miller, The Independent
When it comes to a decreasing lack of public trust it’s politicians who first spring to mind. But the release of the Charity Commission’s report into Oxfam’s sex scandal in Haiti points to another group fast falling from grace: the third sector.
The report found that the charity had a “culture of tolerating poor behaviour” and had “repeatedly fallen below standards expected”. It highlights the failings of a sector still recovering from the Save the Children furore last year and hit again just last week with the allegations that the George Galloway-fronted Viva Palestina delivered no aid despite receiving £1m in donations.
Scandals are rife in every sector but their impact is different. The ongoing Huawei crisis is of course sparking concerns around tech security – yet no one is ditching their iPhone X because of the criticism of Huawei’s phones. However charities of every size are feeling the aftershocks of the abuses of power seen within the sector’s largest players.
This ripple effect isn’t just in the minds of concerned charity CEOs. Research from the Charities Aid Foundation published just last month revealed that both trust and donor numbers suffered a marked decrease between 2016 and 2018. The proportion of people giving money to charity either directly or via sponsorship dropped from 69 per cent to 65 per cent and now less than half – 48 per cent – of people believe that charities are trustworthy.
Whilst the Foundation identified that the reduction in donors was offset by an increase in the total amount of money donated, it’s incredibly worrying to discover that the majority of people don’t think charities are trustworthy.
In addition to being battered by scandals and the resultant drop in public confidence, the third sector is facing competition from a new source: businesses. Brands and for-profit companies are increasingly winning the hearts of consumers through new social initiatives and campaigns, as social consciousness becomes commodified.
Last year’s Edelman earned brand study found that globally 63 per cent of consumers now buy on belief, and as a result businesses are hurrying to update their corporate social responsibility campaigns. Though in itself, this shift is positive – it’s good to see companies putting profit to public service – the knock-on effect is that charities are having to work harder than ever to secure donations. Why would an individual donate to a charity they don’t trust when they believe the money from their latest purchase will have some worthwhile impact anyway? So, how can charities rebuild public trust and what does the third sector need to do to in order to thrive?
Increased “transparency” is usually the first answer given – remove the veil of bureaucracy masking your activities and openly share income and expenditure to demonstrate how donations are used. But it shouldn’t be the conclusive one – it’s only a superficial solution. Only an overhaul of our thinking and of every charity’s structure, though potentially painful, would be able to reverse this downward trend.
What’s needed is a shift in the balance of power and resource allocation towards those delivering projects on the front line. This is particularly the case with international aid, as delivered by the recently scandal-hit large charities, because elaborate theoretical ideas mean nothing without the input of lived experience and a nuanced knowledge of the reality on the ground.
The third sector needs to be selecting the best people to work at grassroots level and then letting their experiences and knowledge lead the strategy. A head office is of course crucial for effective governance, smooth facilitation and fundraising but charities need to structure themselves so that more weight is given to the outreach itself.
At Kidasha, we practice what we preach. Whilst we have a couple of staff in London, the vast majority of our team are in Nepal as that’s the country where we work. And we recruit from local communities wherever possible. In fact, many of our team members delivering aid are those who first benefitted from Kidasha’s support themselves.
Charities also need to rethink the way they measure and communicate the success and impact of their work. All too often we and our donors become overly focussed on cost ratios and whilst of course we have a responsibility to ensure donations are used to the greatest effect, our focus needs to be on maximising impact, rather than reducing costs.
As the media and public chew over the Charity Commission’s findings today and in the coming week, charities of every size and shape need to sit up and take note. The Oxfam scandal isn’t just a sharp reminder for big charities to thoroughly investigate all claims of wrongdoing, but a message to the whole third sector to wake up to the low ebb of trust before it’s too late.
At a time when some 2.2 billion people around the world do not have safely-managed drinking water, as per UN statistics, and 4.2 billion go without safe sanitation services, the “Well of Hope” campaign launched by the UAE has proved that the country is a fountainhead of humanitarian goodness and that
Charitable organisations do work that is praiseworthy and brings succour to the affected. One stellar model is the Emirates Red Crescent (ERC), which has proved it with telling efficacy. Take, for instance, the solidarity and support of the UAE for the hapless Rohingya women and children. Around one million of them now languish
Dubai Cares initiative of setting up a school for the underprivileged in Malawi is a noble gesture. Education is a vital component necessary for the uplifting of the marginalised and so UAE’s drive to do so in Malawi is bound to reap rich dividends in the years to come (“13 UAE volunteers spend a week in Malawi
The gesture by the philanthropic organization Dubai Cares to contribute Dhs2,938,800 ($800,000) over four years to expand the reach of the International Publishers Association’s (IPA) programmes in Africa is praiseworthy. Kenya and Morocco have been identified as initial focus countries, with other beneficiary
It’s the historic and fraternal bonds between the two countries that prompted the UAE to pursue its efforts to restore security and stability in Yemen. As His Highness Sheikh Mohamed Bin Zayed Al Nahyan, Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi and Deputy Supreme Commander of the UAE Armed Forces, pointed out, preserving Yemen’s security and stability
As Democratic presidential contenders race to draft the boldest and most detailed policy plans, President Donald Trump has stuck to the signature issues that helped him win last time: “Build the wall,” “jobs, jobs, jobs” and “America First.” In other words, the agenda for Trump’s second term is largely a set of pithy slogans that have been
Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan’s visit to the US next week is meant to reset Pakistan’s often stormy relations with the US. The first visit by Khan as Prime Minister of Pakistan had been under discussion for some weeks, but Islamabad got a jolt when the State Department spokesperson refuted Pakistani media reports of a meeting
The author-cum-pop psychologist Malcolm Gladwell made a lot of money from telling the world, through his 2008 book Outliers, that anyone can master any skill at all if they just spend 10,000 hours practising it. Eleven years on, he had better hope no one’s been paying too close attention to the somehow still ongoing Tory leadership contest,